Nacirema people and their characteristics
Part A
The words I chose were superstitious, meticulous, devoted, loyal, and sadistic.
The Nacirema follow several processes due to their beliefs. These actions may appear unreasonable to other cultures. In other words, they have some superstitions they follow because it's a part of their culture. One of them is the chest that they keep with the charms and potions. The text states, “In this chest are kept the many charms and magical potions without which no native believes he could live.” These charms and potions may not even have a use after time: “As these magical materials are specific for certain ills, and the real or imagined maladies of the people are many, the charm-box is usually full to overflowing.”
They have specific rituals they perform daily and yearly. One of them is the rite of ablution. The author wrote, “Each day every member of the family, in succession, enters the shrine room, bows his head before the charm-box, mingles different sorts of holy water in the font, and proceeds with a brief rite of ablution.” This is a process with a specialized set of steps to it, which each family member and each member of the community follows faithfully and meticulously.
All members of the Nacirema community do their best to follow their beliefs, despite their social status. One example of this is the use of shrines: “Every household has one or more shrines devoted to this purpose. The more powerful individuals in the society have several shrines in their houses, and, in fact, the opulence of a house is often referred to in terms of the number of such ritual centers it possesses. Most houses are of wattle and daub construction, but their shrine rooms of the more wealthy are walled with stone. Poorer families imitate the rich by applying pottery plaques to their shrine walls.” The families do not allow their situations to stop them from following their beliefs. They do anything in their power to dedicate a room for a shrine and make it look as best as it can.
When facing illnesses, the Nacirema always follow the same protocols, despite there being better alternatives, such as seeing a real doctor. Miner states, “From time to time the medicine men come to their clients and jab magically treated needles into their flesh. The fact that these temple ceremonies may not cure, and may even kill the neophyte, in no way decreases the people’s faith in the medicine men.” The people are loyal to their culture of seeing the medicine men when they are unwell. The Nacirema do not doubt their abilities and continue to put their faith in these rituals.
There are several rites that seem painful but the Nacirema continue to do. Miner wrote about one ritual performed by a holy-mouth-man: “One has to but to watch in the gleam of an eye of a holy-mouth-man, as he jabs an awl into an exposed nerve, to suspect that a certain amount of sadism is involved. If this can be established, a very interesting pattern emerges, for most of the population shows definite masochistic tendencies.” The people have more rituals such as this example that only involve going through pain. They do not rebel against the specialists or leaders because of these rituals, but instead simply follow them continuously. Miner writes about this fact and includes, “The theoretically interesting point is that what seems to be a preponderantly masochistic people have developed sadistic specialists.”
Hello Victoria,
ReplyDeleteI thoroughly enjoyed reading your post. When reading your Part A, I also picked the words "superstitious" and "sadistic" to be biased; therefore, when reading your Part B, I was glad to see you had the same idea. It reassured me that we both understood the assignments given to us. I believe the new words "ceremonial" and "strong/enduring" were great alternatives that allow for a positive connotation to be perceived rather than a negative one.
- EClark ^
ReplyDeleteMy initial comment from Wednesday confirming your submission is missing. I'll repost. Part A submission confirmed.
ReplyDeletePart B Comment: I'll start by listing your choice of five words from Part A.
ReplyDeletesuperstitious
meticulous
devoted
loyal
sadistic
1. "American culture is filled with several laws and habits that other cultures may not have."
Yes, some aspects of American culture can be described with these terms, but Minor isn't describing American culture in general. He is describing very specific aspects of it, namely portions or our health care practices, things like dental care and visiting a hospital. So when you look at the words you chose, do those accurately describe how we brush our teeth? Or go to the dentist? Or visit our doctor? THAT is the question you need to ask yourself here.
2. Keep in mind that just because a term gives a positive connotation doesn't mean it isn't biased in some way. "Bias" just means the impression is altered based upon prior experience and preconceptions. This could be a bias in a good OR a bad way.
So, yes, 'superstitious' and 'sadistic' both have negative connotations, but positive terms like "loyal" and "devoted" can also be biased. The question is not about positive or negative but *accuracy*. So Minor is describing some of our health care practices, such as brushing our teeth. Do your words help a reader understand our behavior of brushing our teeth? Is the description accurate? Is it useful?
3. I appreciate your attempt to find better words "superstitious". That said recognize that the difficulty in choosing alternate words may not lie with the words themselves but the process of describing this culture in the first place. Part of what I want you to understand here is that you chose these words based upon a biased narrative...Horace Minor's narrative was designed to be a biased outsider's view of this culture, so nearly all words you choose are going to perpetuate that bias. It might be better to recognize that this attempt to define a culture with individual words isn't possible in the first place. It is a futile and biased practice and doesn't reflect what anthropologists are trying to do in their jobs. As an anthropologist, your job is to not describe from an outsider's perspective but to understand a culture.. and that means starting to see it as insiders do.
4. "I think it is not possible to completely avoid personal cultural bias as a cultural anthropologist."
I tend to agree, but then how can we address this issue? While Anthropologists can strive to avoid bias and practice this skill, I suggest it is just as important to be aware that our biases are deeply ingrained in our psyche and are likely impossible to avoid completely. Better to be aware of this and be receptive to those who point it out when it happens. This is one of the reasons anthropologists collaborate with others... so that they can watch out for each other's bias seeping into their work.
Good Day Victoria. I quite enjoyed reading your post. I liked your use of words on part one and as I read the second part I thought about your words again. I think that the words you stated as biased indeed are biased, however, I think that in a way these words do apply to our American culture. For example, I think that in a way our culture is very superstitious. We have many beliefs that are baked into us that may be false despite ourselves. For example, to another outside observer we have many superstitious traditions. The fact that many skyscrapers we see do not contain a thirteenth floor. This is because of the fear of the number 13. We can also think of sports day traditions such as wearing your team's jersey. These are all supersitiuous things we do as a culture.
ReplyDelete